Futa Tagging Question

Posted under General

I'm curious as to how people out there would tag pictures with futanari in them when it comes to counting up the characters in the picture.

I've seen some where the futa characters are counted as girls, some where they're counted strictly as futas, and some where it's a combination of the two.

As an example, let's say you have a picture where a boy is being spitroasted by 2 futanari girls while a regular girl looks on. (I'll let your imaginations come up with the context for such an image.) How would you tag the 4 characters?

(On an unrelated note, did you come up with anything interesting to fill the context for this hypothetical image? I'd love to see what this set of minds could come up with.)

To be completely honest, I've only seen futa tagged as its own thing at rule34.xxx so I'd just tag futas as girls in any situation, and always tag penetration as sex, its own distinct tag depending on the orifice and so on.

In my eyes it's rather straightforward, but I'm not sure how everyone else tags such things, so don't quote me on this.

"nobody is perfect".
futas are intersex people, not girls and not boys. please dont tag them as girls.

1futa
2futas
3futas are the correct tags.

namekianer said:

"nobody is perfect".
futas are intersex people, not girls and not boys. please dont tag them as girls.

1futa
2futas
3futas are the correct tags.

i.e. 1futa and such, sounds like a way to go.

Apologies about the previous post then, generally we just went with girl tags a few years ago at Danbooru at least, but for organizing purposes, you have a point.

If I had to pick male or female, I would pick male, because of the presence of the penis. But that shows the exact root of the problem. And fortunately Namekainer has a viable solution that sidesteps the whole question, considering them not male or female but their own set of tags.

Thanks SisterTea and Leortha. I always try to solve problems and good when my comment was helpful.

Oh and the child version of a intersex: young_futanari / young_newhalf

@Jay19: you mean this genderswap characters i have found here?

Updated

A cuntboy is the exact opposite of a dickgirl/futa. All features look male. Flat chest, male facial structure, male musculature. But a pussy down below. It's much rarer to see than a futa. While I have never gone looking for them, I've only ever stumbled across a image of one once, and that was in the flood of AI gen art pics from 4chan that I was posting over on the other side of the site.

I will also note that, in my mind, a young female who presents male does not necessarily count. Aura from Overlord, Ed from Cowboy Bebop, and Pidge from LD Voltron are cases where I would not necessarily apply the term, despite them all being females who normally present as male. I guess the difference is, with those three, once clothes are removed, they generally look female. A true cuntboy looks male, clothed or not, except for where it counts.

Updated

JustWatching27 said:

As an example, let's say you have a picture where a boy is being spitroasted by 2 futanari girls while a regular girl looks on. (I'll let your imaginations come up with the context for such an image.) How would you tag the 4 characters?

(On an unrelated note, did you come up with anything interesting to fill the context for this hypothetical image? I'd love to see what this set of minds could come up with.)

To answer your first question:
1 Boy
2 Futas
1 Girl

Even though futas may have the body of a female, the futa tag should be used for them, not female.

As for your second question:
Shota Ben tennyson getting spitroasted by a Futa Starfire and a Futa Raven while Gwen Tennyson watches from the back.

jay19 said:

Now the question is how does one tag a “Cuntboy”?

Newhalf...

But what about "male futas"? (They have both a dick and a pussy, but everything else about them appears "male)

Then there's the distinction between:

•Futa: appears "female" but has both a dick and a pussy
•dick girl: has the overall appearance of a "female", has a dick but lacks a pussy

Somewhat related, but some booru sites have started to tag new uploads for Bridget_(guilty_gear) as "Loli dick_girl transgender", where older images (uploaded before September 2022) get to keep the shota tag

In the above example, "futa" isn't used, because there's a distinct lack of a pussy

MrPib said:

Newhalf...

But what about "male futas"? (They have both a dick and a pussy, but everything else about them appears "male)

Then there's the distinction between:

•Futa: appears "female" but has both a dick and a pussy
•dick girl: has the overall appearance of a "female", has a dick but lacks a pussy

Somewhat related, but some booru sites have started to tag new uploads for Bridget_(guilty_gear) as "Loli dick_girl transgender", where older images (uploaded before September 2022) get to keep the shota tag

In the above example, "futa" isn't used, because there's a distinct lack of a pussy

In the particular case of Bridget, I've always gone with otoko_no_ko, much like Astolfo and such and tagged him as a boy because the entire "trap" thing.

Not sure how everyone else tags in such cases, or if Danbooru's "tag what you see, not what you know" rule applies, but it'd be interesting to reach a consensus about all these topics.

this crap confuses me lol. i dont get technical if i see a dick girls i add futanari or 1futa and thats is. and for pussy boys i just genderswap them.

MrPib said:

Newhalf...

the tag is used for a person with: a penis and breasts.

i agree with DTMC. it seems all the uploads here are genderswap of already existing people (like ash/satoshi from pokemon).
so we should tag them with genderswap.

namekianer said:

Thanks SisterTea and Leortha. I always try to solve problems and good when my comment was helpful.

Oh and the child version of a intersex: young_futanari / young_newhalf

@Jay19: you mean this genderswap characters i have found here?

No, it's a joke. If a futa is tagged as 1futa, 2futas, etc
Then a cuntboy is tagged as 1cunt, 2cunts, etc lmao

And @MrPib don't use newhalf for cuntboy. A cuntboy is an intersex person like futa is an intersex person but leans more male.

Newhalf i believe is specifically for trans indivuals. A new half such as Bridget who previous identified as male but now identifies as a girl.

On a more personal matter. Cuntboys don't show up that often but even though they are intersex. I would like people to identify them as the gender the artist refers to them as.

For example Anomin i believes refers to his cuntboy as girls.
Another artists may refer to their cuntboys as boys.

I realize this may get confusing but i don't see too many people here looking cuntboys so it shouldn't be too much of an issue.

jay19 said:

Newhalf I believe is specifically for trans individuals. A new half such as Bridget who previous identified as male but now identifies as a girl.

Ok, I looked it up..

previously it meant "cuntboy" (looks male but has a pussy and lacks a dick) or "dickgirl" (looks like a girl but has a dick and lacks a pussy)

but as of 2018, it now means "pre-op transgender"

and yes, Bridget would now be considered a newhalf, dickgirl and a loli

this post #345549, shows a newhalf / dickgirl. it SHOULD NOT be tagged as futanari.

And I will agree, transgender characters are tricky... I got yelled at by REDACTED over on Uli's Discord a while back, for putting "Felis Argyle" in the shota section
(the author supposedly decided halfway through the web novel that the character was transgender, but the manga and anime stuck with the "femboy" cliché)

Updated

1