I had uploaded two guro images recently that depicted baby shotas after fellatio given to them by bearded men.
by redpanel: *link removed*
by stonetoss : *link removed*
They were deleted by an unknown mod who cited reasons "antisemitism" and "Antisemitic propaganda"
This does not appear to be justified under the rules as listed. Is there a new rule on the books which hasn't been listed yet?
Firstly, even if you view this as criticism of the Jewish religion (it could easily be intended as a CELEBRATION, who knows?) the Jewish religion is not the Semitic races.
The Semitic languages/races include a wide collection of cultures including Arabic/Aramaic/Hebrew/Maltese and even if something was critical just of the Hebrew people, you would call it "anti-Hebrew" not "anti-Semitic".
Criticism of a religion would not however constitute criticism of people of Hebrew ancestry, since that does not obligate them to continue all the cultural practices of their forefathers.
This would for example be tantamount to calling it "racist" to be critical of the human sacrifices practiced by ancient Aztec priests, as if it implies some kind of bias against their descendants who do not practice human sacrifice.
https://booru.allthefallen.moe/static/terms_of_servic only has a single statement about racism, duplicated under the FORUM and COMMENTS sections: "Don't be an asshole. Don't insult other users, don't be a racist, etc."
Images themselves (and their tags) are not comments/forum and banning images on the basis of "racism" is a very slippery slope that will quell free expression.
For example is this racist? https://booru.allthefallen.moe/posts/298021
How about this? https://booru.allthefallen.moe/posts/304645
We should be able to depict racism in characters, but banning the subject of racism prevents that, and in an age where progressively EVERYTHING is getting called racist and cancelled on that basis, the last thing we need is more censorship and a wedge tool when clearly we are anti-cancel free expression except for shit like 3d which risks CP charges.
The purpose of artwork here is not necessarily to arouse: there's a lot of scat/guro which I think is just posted for shock value, for example. There's some really sad-ending loli mangas out there. I might not fap to it, but if it's interesting or well-drawn I will still upload it because I believe in archiving things. We should consider ourselves historians: while we might spend more time on stuff we like, we also have a moral duty to archive stuff we dislike too, if it's on-topic.
There are plenty of Semitic people (including those of Hebrew ancestry) who do not engage in fellatio with babies. Mohels are only a small portion of rabbis, and rabbis are only a small portion of Jewish men, and Jewish men are only half of Jews.
Although metzitza b'peh has been practiced by rabbinites for centuries, there's a modern variation where suction of foreskin blood is performed via a glass pipette instead of the mouth, for example. It is only orthodox mohels who still practise in the classic fellatio fashion.
We have a moral responsibility not only to defend stuff we fap to, but also social commentary which highlight actual IRL historical child abuses in a tasteful (bad choice of word?) way.
Updated by user 2041