Harvey Street Kids / Harvey Girls Forever nuked by Paheal: what % do we have here?

Posted under General

I can't remember how big the tag got before Paheal mods decided to nuke fucking EVERYTHING recently.

There's 124 listed here now, anyone estimate how much Paheal was up to?

At the very least I wish they would do an archive of the tag so we could see thumbnails and get an idea of the number we might be missing...

KittyGirl45 said:

Wait until the underage content is gone then reload them.

they might ban people doing that if they catch on

the most important thing is backing it up here BEFORE it's gone

even if your intent was to skirt the deletions it would be important to have backups organized

tyciol said:

they might ban people doing that if they catch on

the most important thing is backing it up here BEFORE it's gone

even if your intent was to skirt the deletions it would be important to have backups organized

They also deleted a drawing of Audrey I made and I can't upload it here because I know it won't pass quality standards for sure. I even tried emailing them and they said it's something to do with the server they work for.

at least if stuff here is deleted for quality standards it's a soft delete so you can still find it by searching the tag and clicking 'deleted images', and a direct URL to it will still work even though it's hidden from standard searches

this at least keeps a record, they only hard-delete actual CP or realistic reproductions in 3d as they ought to

tyciol said:

at least if stuff here is deleted for quality standards it's a soft delete so you can still find it by searching the tag and clicking 'deleted images', and a direct URL to it will still work even though it's hidden from standard searches

this at least keeps a record, they only hard-delete actual CP or realistic reproductions in 3d as they ought to

We might change our quality standards as this situation is a bit more unique. However, people like you who don't mind these types of artworks aren't the only one here, and we have had numerous complaints before about being too lenient and allowing "low quality art" to pass through. We have to find a balance to please everyone, so we try not accepting just everything. We know art is art, but technically anyone can make art, it doesn't have to be good. However, if someone searches for a tag like "cum" and half of what they find is very amateurish looking stuff that most people probably don't like, then it becomes annoying for them as well.

It's easy to judge low effort stuff like edits that clearly degrade quality of the original, but it's harder to judge something that's simply made by someone who isn't a very skilled artist (like bad body proportions).

Updated

I think the only way you would be allowed to upload loli or shota content to Paheal is by censoring any genital areas such as penises, nipples, vaginas, breasts, anus's, etc. However I do understand that censoring basically beats the whole purpose of porn in the first place but all you would have to do is draw a black line over a penis and it doesn't even have to be the whole thing. Just censor one part of a character's genitalia and I think you should be able to upload this type of content without it being deleted.

I'm still a little mad that Paheal deleted my drawing of Audrey Smith which I also tried uploading here but then the same thing happened here but for quality standards. But I knew it was gonna get deleted for that. However I uploaded it after reading thatenemy's reply in this forum.

I wanted to upload it here because I don't know any other sites that allow underage content that doesn't have quality standards. Yes, I have tried to appeal it but haven't got a response to it yet.

Anyways, but yeah. I think the only way to actually keep this type of stuff uploaded there without it being deleted is by censoring the image.

thatenemy said:

people like you who don't mind these types of artworks aren't the only one here
we have had numerous complaints before about being too lenient and allowing "low quality art" to pass through We have to find a balance to please everyone
so we try not accepting just everything

https://booru.allthefallen.moe/settings has a "comment threshold" where it defaults to hiding comments rated lower than -1 (I like to see badly ranked comments so I changed it to -999 just now)

Why don't we just have something like this for images where we rate images up or down, and people can have the option of hiding badly-rated images?

We know art is art,
but technically anyone can make art,
it doesn't have to be good.

I'm hoping you can at least be more tolerable of low quality when it comes to rare rule 34 characters who have little else but 1 or 2 attempts at them.

If it's a character who has hundreds/thousands then I don't entirely mind deleting the crappy ones.

However, if someone searches for a tag like "cum" and half of what they find is very amateurish looking stuff that most people probably don't like, then it becomes annoying for them as well.

Adding 'highres' to the search would probably solve a lot of those problems.

Maybe we could just have a 'highquality' tag to include (or 'lowquality' tag to minus) to allow them to shape their searches without hiding results?

It's easy to judge low effort stuff like edits that clearly degrade quality of the original, but it's harder to judge something that's simply made by someone who isn't a very skilled artist (like bad body proportions).

not to mention characters who are actually drawn that way to begin with

for example: https://rule34.paheal.net/post/view/7751

That might be rejected as 'shitty art' but to anyone who's watched the show, that's what they actually look like.

tyciol said:

https://booru.allthefallen.moe/settings has a "comment threshold" where it defaults to hiding comments rated lower than -1 (I like to see badly ranked comments so I changed it to -999 just now)

Why don't we just have something like this for images where we rate images up or down, and people can have the option of hiding badly-rated images?

I'm hoping you can at least be more tolerable of low quality when it comes to rare rule 34 characters who have little else but 1 or 2 attempts at them.

If it's a character who has hundreds/thousands then I don't entirely mind deleting the crappy ones.

Adding 'highres' to the search would probably solve a lot of those problems.

Maybe we could just have a 'highquality' tag to include (or 'lowquality' tag to minus) to allow them to shape their searches without hiding results?

not to mention characters who are actually drawn that way to begin with

for example: https://rule34.paheal.net/post/view/7751

That might be rejected as 'shitty art' but to anyone who's watched the show, that's what they actually look like.

I wish we had a Harvey Street Kids booru porn site similar to this one. If there was a site like that we wouldn’t have to worry about any damn rules. I do know a site that allows you to create your own booru site.

You can create one here.
https://booru.org/

tyciol said:

https://booru.allthefallen.moe/settings has a "comment threshold" where it defaults to hiding comments rated lower than -1 (I like to see badly ranked comments so I changed it to -999 just now)

Why don't we just have something like this for images where we rate images up or down, and people can have the option of hiding badly-rated images?

I'm hoping you can at least be more tolerable of low quality when it comes to rare rule 34 characters who have little else but 1 or 2 attempts at them.

If it's a character who has hundreds/thousands then I don't entirely mind deleting the crappy ones.

Adding 'highres' to the search would probably solve a lot of those problems.

Maybe we could just have a 'highquality' tag to include (or 'lowquality' tag to minus) to allow them to shape their searches without hiding results?

not to mention characters who are actually drawn that way to begin with

for example: https://rule34.paheal.net/post/view/7751

That might be rejected as 'shitty art' but to anyone who's watched the show, that's what they actually look like.

Sorry for the late reply, I have been busy.

As far as I know this isn't possible to do that. You can sort by score however, but that doesn't seem very useful in this case. Regardless, score wouldn't be a good way to sort out this stuff anyway, since there are people into certain shows even if the art isn't really good. It's like a guro upload getting a high score, even though most people wouldn't like it. At least in that case you can avoid it because "guro" can be blacklisted.

Although there already is enough subjectivity involded in determining what kind of art is good enough, and what counts as a loli or a teen, I don't want to add another layer by approving something based on how much content is already available. We might change our standards in the future, it wouldn't be too late since deleted uploads are still present.

A tag solution might help, but I'll have to think about it.

Please know that we do not know every source material, nor should it matter in the first place.

1